Why EAs often fail prop firm challenges
Most EAs fail prop firm challenges not because the strategy is bad, but because they break the rules: the daily loss limit is exceeded just because of an open trade, trading happens during banned news times, or a VPS restart makes the EA "forget" its old orders.
6 must-have rules
- Daily loss limit including open trades. Many firms calculate it from the balance or equity at the start of the day. The EA must track it exactly the way the firm does and close all orders before reaching the limit.
- Maximum loss limit. Calculate it correctly as either the fixed or the trailing type the firm uses.
- Lock trading for the rest of the day after hitting a limit, even if you restart MetaTrader.
- Block high-impact news times if the firm bans them, with a buffer before and after the news.
- Risk per trade as a % of the account, not a fixed lot size.
- Pick orders back up after a restart. The EA must recognize its own orders by magic number and not open duplicates.
The firm's start of day usually follows the firm's server time, not your local time. This mismatch is a very common mistake.
Checks before the challenge
- Read the firm's rules carefully and note down every number.
- Backtest with spreads and fees matching the challenge account.
- Run a trial on the firm's own demo account (if available) for at least a week.
- Shut down the VPS midway to see whether the EA picks its orders back up.
Need a ready-made tool? See the ready-made products. Need a custom EA built to your firm's rules? See custom EA pricing.